Does he beat out Guest Verified for you? (Cuz he does for me.)
They are about equal. Matthew is devoid of humour. His life is about railing at injustices, either real or perceived. He is a foul-tempered, sour little man who is eaten up by his own hate.
Guest Verified is equally fucked up in the religion department, but he likes nothing better than to taunt, mock, and push buttons. He is as difficult to corner as Amos, in that he will never allow his own ego to publicly admit he has been cornered, so he dodges, moves goalposts, plays games, changes the subject, or abandons his own point in favour of accusing his opponent of being a sock account.
So you want to smack both of them in the mouth, but it's hard to say whose smack would provide the greater satisfaction.