FSTDT Forums

Community => Science and Technology => Topic started by: Askold on July 17, 2015, 12:58:01 am

Title: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Askold on July 17, 2015, 12:58:01 am
http://futurism.com/links/view/uh-oh-a-robot-just-passed-the-famed-self-awareness-test/

Three robots were put into a classic test of self awareness and one of them passed the test. The test doesn't seem particularly complicated to a human but I suppose having a robot beat it does seem impressive.

Quote
-In the puzzle, a fictional king is choosing a new advisor and gathers the three wisest people in the land. He promises the contest will be fair, then puts either a blue or white hat on each of their heads and tells them all that the first person to stand up and correctly deduce the colour of their own hat will become his new advisor.
-Selmer Bringsjord set up a similar situation for the three robots – two were prevented from talking, then all three were asked which one was still able to speak. All attempt to say “I don’t know”, but only one succeeds – and when it hears its own voice, it understands that it was not silenced, saying “Sorry, I know now!”
-It might sound a pretty simple task for a human, but it’s not for a robot – the bot must listen to and understand the question, then hear their own voice saying “I don’t know” and recognise it as distinct from another robot’s voice, then connect that with the original question to conclude that they hadn’t been silenced.
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Tolpuddle Martyr on July 17, 2015, 06:33:16 am
How does the robot distinguish between the voices?
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: R. U. Sirius on July 17, 2015, 10:27:38 am
How does the robot distinguish between the voices?

Probably the same way your voice sounds different to you than it does to other people.
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Askold on July 17, 2015, 11:41:24 am
How does the robot distinguish between the voices?

Probably the same way your voice sounds different to you than it does to other people.

...That would in itself be an achievement in AI design as far as I understand.
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Ultimate Paragon on July 17, 2015, 12:48:08 pm
Science is wonderful, isn't it?
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: ironbite on July 17, 2015, 01:00:23 pm
I've seen how this movie ends.
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Sigmaleph on July 17, 2015, 04:16:11 pm
OK, what the hell. I assume this is a poorly-reported version of an actual story, but as it is its is meaningless

1) That is not how the blue/white hat puzzle works! At all! If it did, it would not be a puzzle!

2)  What exactly were they testing, a general reasoning scheme that can observe "Only one robot can talk -> I try to talk -> I talk -> That robot is me". Because depending on what you start with, that can be trivial or not. But more important, that's an AI test, why are they doing it with robots rather than just in a computer?

3) Is auditory recognition important? Is that what they were testing?

4) The hell does this have to do with self-awareness? Is it just that the robot recognised itself as the one that spoke? Because that sort of self concept can be trivially programmed.

5) gaaaaaah this is so frustrating.

As an aside, this is the blue/white hat puzzle:

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Askold on July 18, 2015, 12:14:43 am
Here is the incident in video.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MceJYhVD_xY

I wonder why the other two robots aren't getting up?

http://www.techradar.com/news/world-of-tech/uh-oh-this-robot-just-passed-the-self-awareness-test-1299362

The comments are awesome. This test was a liberal conspiracy to lower the value of humanity and pushing forwards the atheist agenda.
Title: Re: Signs of self awareness observed in a robot
Post by: Sigmaleph on July 18, 2015, 12:32:07 am
OK, the video is pretty cool. But it looks like almost all of the reply is written in specifically to maximise empathy? Like, having the robot say "sorry" and stuff. Also doing it with cute robots with auditory processing and not with just software.

It's a pretty cool thing to watch, but the coolness and the science seem dissociated. The actual breakthrough appears to be something called Deontic Cognitive Event Calculus which is apparently what the AI used to prove it was the one that didn't get muted.

It's probably easier to get people to talk about cute robots that respond to verbal questions that to implementations of modal logic.